Introduction
Internationalization of business activities is central to increased profitability and global presence. As a publicly listed company in Hong Kong, the firm began operations in India and plans further expansion in the country. Although the move is financially viable for Starbucks Corporation, staff recruitment and talent management are significant problems. Therefore, recruiting culturally aware staff and fostering a high-performance culture in talent management are crucial for Starbucks.
Company Background
Starbucks is a global company that operates in different countries across the world. The organization’s history dates back to 1971, when it was founded by Jerry Baldwin, Zev Siegl, and Gordon Bowker (Liu, Li, and Lin, 2022). In 1980, the firm was sold to Howard Schultz, who turned it into a coffeehouse that served espresso-based drinks. In addition to coffee drinks, Starbucks serves food and official merchandise. Tumblers, mugs, scoops, and coffee pressers are the company’s official merchandise sold to clients.
Unlike other companies, Starbucks is known for its unique and broad product and service offerings that appeal to the global market. Some of the unique products sold by Starbucks Corporation include Ethos drinks, Oleato, barrel-aged coffee, and non-dairy milk offerings (Liu, Li, and Lin, 2022). While its headquarters are in Seattle, the firm operates in about 36,171 locations open across 83 countries (Sihombing and Lestari, 2022). China and the U.S. have the largest location share, with about 61% (Tenbarge, 2023). Consequently, the firm has been actively expanding its activities into other countries, such as Hong Kong and India.
Expansion Plan and Human Resource (HR) Challenges
Expansion Plan
Increased competition and the need for an excellent brand have driven Starbucks to expand into the Indian market. The firm began operations in Hong Kong in May 2000 and has opened about 147 stores across commercial, shopping, entertainment, and residential areas in the country. However, the company began its Indian operations in October 2012, following a failed attempt in 2007 (Starbucks, 2022).
Consequently, in February 2023, Starbucks released its expansion rollout plan for the Asia Pacific (Tenbarge, 2023). The plan requires the company to intensify its Indian operations by expanding into at least 5 new cities (Starbucks, 2022). Staff recruitment and talent management are issues that should be addressed to enable effective and profitable internationalization.
Staff Recruitment Challenges
Challenge Context
Starbucks Corporation’s success is anchored in its practical and friendly corporate culture. Meanwhile, distinguished from other countries, Indians place a high value on collectivism and harmony (Sihombing and Lestari, 2022). The firm must align its clients’ culture with its recruitment strategy (Leinwand, Mani, and Sheppard, 2022). Additionally, the recruits should manifest Starbucks’ culture during their employment. Although India has a large population of potential Starbucks employees, recruiting culturally competent individuals can be problematic for the company’s HR department.
Root Causes
Difficulty in recruiting culturally competent employees stems from various root causes. Compared to countries such as the U.S. and China, where Starbucks dominates, there is limited local expertise within the Indian market (Starbucks, 2022). For instance, the existing Starbucks locations in India are insufficient at exposing locals to the company’s culture and operating practices.
Additionally, cultural gaps between the Indian market and other operating areas make it difficult to identify competent recruits (Kumar et al., 2023). Although Indians are generally known for a collectivist, harmonious culture, they have unique ways of life that vary by locality (Kitayama et al., 2022). Limited local expertise and cultural gaps hinder Starbucks’s recruitment of competent employees in India.
Affected Stakeholders
Starbucks customers in India are affected because employees provide poor service. Poor services can be detrimental to the satisfaction levels of Starbucks’ customers in India (Neeley and Leonardi, 2022). Shareholders can also be affected by poor service, which is associated with decreased returns on investment (Ely and Thomas, 2020). Furthermore, the firm’s HR team is affected, as their effectiveness in recruiting competent employees is negatively impacted. Therefore, culturally incompetent employees can be detrimental to consumers, shareholders, and the HR team.
The Difference Between Hong Kong and India
Hong Kong is one of the largest cities in China and is an administrative region of the country. In contrast to India, Hong Kong primarily has a mix of Chinese and Western influences (Kumar et al., 2023). As an American company, Starbucks Corporation has its organizational culture and values anchored in Western values. Consequently, it is easier to recruit culturally competent employees in Hong Kong than in India. Additionally, the availability of individuals who have experienced both Western and Asian cultures makes Hong Kong more viable for upholding the company’s values while meeting customer expectations.
Another significant difference in the context of staff recruitment issues between Hong Kong and India is the duration of operations. In contrast to India, Starbucks has been present in Hong Kong for approximately 23 years (Starbucks, 2022). Consequently, more potential recruits have interacted with the company in Hong Kong than in India. The prospective recruits in Hong Kong are more aware of the company’s culture and can effectively integrate it into their routine operations as Starbucks employees. The cultural differences and operational duration between Hong Kong and India make it more challenging to identify culturally aware recruits in India.
Managers’ Experience and Solutions
Difficulty finding culture-aware employees is a growing challenge for organizations considering international expansion. The use of expatriates in a foreign country is a common approach to fostering organizational culture in the new country of operations (Liu, Li and Lin, 2022). The expatriates know the organizational culture and help the new employees to get acquainted with it (Kitayama et al., 2022). The recruits can understand how their organization handles various cases and behaves by observing the expatriates.
Additionally, HR managers consider cultural awareness training programs effective. The programs involve experts who have sufficient knowledge of the organization and local culture. Localization of organizational activities is another approach managers use. Multinational organizations consider the ways of life of the communities they serve and align them with their organizational culture (Fayard, Weeks, and Khan, 2021). Similar to other HR managers, Starbucks Corporation can consider localization, cultural awareness training, and the use of expatriates.
Talent Management
Challenge Context
Talent management involves recruiting productive employees and retaining them to sustain their exemplary performance over time. Compared to other countries where Starbucks Corporation operates, India is a developing country. Poor economic conditions are associated with a need for high-paying employment opportunities (Serafeim, 2020).
The company may have problems retaining its employees in the market. Additionally, the HR department may have difficulty meeting new employees’ expectations during Starbucks’s operations. Talent management problems are associated with poor organizational performance, as recruits who fail to work at Starbucks for extended periods provide inconsistent service.
Root Causes
Various factors are associated with Starbucks’ talent management problem. Given India’s economic conditions, employee expectations are changing over time. For instance, the majority of employees would expect highly competitive salaries as they continue working at the new Starbucks areas of operation (Yahui et al., 2023). If the company fails to meet such expectations, the employees may seek better jobs from other firms.
Moreover, increased competition from other organizations such as Cafe Coffee Day, Blue Tokai Coffee, and McDonald’s McCafe. Some competitors, such as CafĂ© Coffee Day, dominate the Indian market and offer more competitive salaries (Kutieshat and Farmanesh, 2022). Consequently, the majority of Starbucks’ Indian employees may seek job opportunities from competitors.
Affected Stakeholders
Poor talent management can affect stakeholders across Starbucks Corporation. The clients will be highly dissatisfied because competent, customer-friendly employees will leave the company. On the other hand, Starbucks’ shareholders in India will experience low returns on their investments due to adverse effects on the firm’s overall performance (Liu, 2022). Furthermore, HR department employees will have difficulty constantly searching for skilled employees (Ghani et al., 2022). Therefore, the company may incur financial losses, as its competent employees are likely to be absorbed by competitors in the sector.
The Difference between Hong Kong and India
Political, economic, and social differences between Hong Kong and Singapore make the face of the talent management problem different in each. Unlike India, Hong Kong has better economic conditions. Consequently, it will be difficult for employees to feel an urge to seek better jobs (Yahui et al., 2023).
Additionally, Starbucks has been operating in Hong Kong for more years than in India. Therefore, the individual and economic needs of Hong Kong employees are well-known. Politically, Hong Kong has a more favorable legal and political climate for workers’ needs and rights (Yahui et al., 2023). Talent management is easier in Hong Kong than in India.
Managers’ Experience and Solutions
Managers who have experienced difficulties in talent management have applied various approaches. Use of job descriptions that capture key aspects of employment, including compensation plans, can help (Shih and Morlinghaus, 2020). Additionally, providing opportunities for professional development has increased employee satisfaction.
Consequently, the majority tend to remain in their organizations (Muleya, Ngirande, and Terera, 2022). The availability of employee backup plans helps organizations easily replace employees who quit for better opportunities (Livingston, 2020). Optimizing job descriptions, backup plans, and professional development opportunities can address talent management problems.
Problems Analysis
Talent management and staff recruitment challenges negatively affect Starbucks’ operations in India. As a global brand, the organization enjoys an excellent reputation. However, if it loses effective and skilled employees, the majority of customers will have a negative attitude towards the firm in India (Liu, 2022).
Recruiting culturally insensitive employees is associated with unethical customer service, which may exacerbate organizational performance. Moreover, failure to retain competitive employees may cause the customers to go to Starbucks’ competitors. A lack of market competitiveness can lead to high costs and losses (Ghani et al., 2022). Therefore, Starbucks must solve the challenges associated with talent management and staff recruitment.
Problem Solving, Negative and Positive Impacts
Various approaches can be adopted to overcome talent management and staff recruitment challenges. The organization can adopt continuous learning and professional development activities for its recruits in India (Yahui et al., 2023). The training programs can focus on Starbucks’ culture and values in the Indian context.
Moreover, offering competitive salaries will encourage employees to remain with the organization (Hassan, 2022). On the other hand, the company can focus on localizing its staff recruitment process to ensure that only individuals familiar with Indian culture are selected (Liu, 2022). Furthermore, the company can use expatriates from countries such as China, where its operations are successful. The latter will help teach recruits about Starbucks’ culture and successful strategies as applied in other countries.
Solving the talent management and staff recruitment challenges presents both negative and positive impacts. With the problems solved, the company will record increased profits due to its broad customer base. Consequently, sufficient funds are available for other investment and operational improvement activities (Al Ahbabi and Nobanee, 2019).
Another positive impact is an improved organizational brand in India, driven by cordial relationships between employees and clients. On the negative side, adopting strategies to address the issues can be costly for the company. Given its small presence in India, it may become difficult to sustain the business in the short term. The benefits of solving the problems outweigh the drawbacks.
Potential Upgrade and Improvement Areas
Although Starbucks can solve the presented problem to its advantage, several areas need improvement. The company needs to optimize its presence on Indian social media to attract loyal customers and attract potential employees (Yahui et al., 2023). Additionally, the firm’s recruitment team in India should be structured in a manner that is diverse and consistent with Indian culture.
Including individuals who have long-term experience in India can be beneficial when interviewing prospective recruits (Hassan, 2022). Furthermore, the company’s research and development department should be upgraded to ensure that new locations are attractive to customers and accessible to employees. Improving the highlighted areas is central to effectively solving the challenges of talent management and staff recruitment in India.
Recommendations
Proposed Action Plan
Following the problem analysis, employee training, competitive salaries, and localization of staff recruitment are the best solutions. Therefore, the company can adopt an initiative that addresses the cultural needs of the Indian population. Employee training can involve cultural and communication experts who guide workers on ethical practices.
Experts can be invited every 3 months during a given financial year as part of a long-term action plan. Meanwhile, the company can invite expatriates from other countries who will interact with the recruits for the short term. The expatriates may leave India after 1 month, which is sufficient time for the recruits to understand Starbucks’ culture and operating model. As a long-term measure, the company can increase employees’ salaries every 6 months for 3 years.
Pros and Cons of the Plan
Adopting a cultural training program and increasing salaries have both merits and demerits. The main benefit of the proposed actions is that they will lead to competitive and culturally sensitive employees. Consequently, Starbucks will save on recruiting and retaining costs.
Additionally, the company will retain its excellent brand image and reputation as it starts new operations in the Indian market (Liu, 2022). Meanwhile, the disadvantage of the plan is that it is resource-consuming. The training programs, the hiring of expatriates, and the rising salaries are costly for Starbucks. The resources invested in the action plan can be used to boost other business activities.
Required Resources and Potential Outcomes
Human and financial resources are needed to execute the proposed action plan successfully. Cultural experts, trainers, and program managers are needed for the training programs. Although the approach is costly, it will lead to positive outcomes for the employees and organization. The workers will learn new skills and become culturally sensitive in the Indian context. Meanwhile, the firm will benefit from reduced costs and increased profits in the long term (Yahui et al., 2023). Investing in talent management and staff recruitment will enable Starbucks to set up its new locations in the Indian market effectively.
Conclusion
Starbucks is an American multinational organization that operates in Hong Kong. The firm plans to expand its operations in India but may face challenges in talent management and recruitment. Consequently, adopting competitive salaries and localizing staff recruitment will help address these challenges. The proposed action plan is associated with high costs but with positive outcomes. Therefore, Starbucks needs to allocate resources to employee training and localize its recruitment approach to achieve successful expansion in the Indian market.
Reference List
Al Ahbabi, A.R. and Nobanee, H. (2019) ‘Conceptual building of sustainable financial management & sustainable financial growth‘, Papers SSRN.
Ely, R. and Thomas, D. (2020) “Enough already with the business case getting serious about diversity”, Harvard Business Review, 98(6), pp.114–122.
Fayard, A.-L., Weeks, J. and Khan, M. (2021) “Organizational culture designing the hybrid office“, Harvard Business Review, 98(1), pp.76–83.
Ghani, B. et al. (2022) ‘Challenges and strategies for employee retention in the hospitality industry: a review‘, Sustainability,14(5).
Hassan, Z. (2022) ‘Employee retention through effective human resource management practices in Maldives: mediation effects of compensation and rewards system’, Journal of Entrepreneurship, Management and Innovation, 18(2), pp.137–174.
Kitayama, S. et al. (2022) ‘Varieties of interdependence and the emergence of the Modern West: Toward the globalizing of psychology’, American Psychologist, 77(9), pp.991–1006.
Kumar, A. et al. (2023) ‘Human resource management in the retail sector: challenges and trends’, International Journal of Multidisciplinary: Applied Business and Education Research, 4(6), pp. 2086–2093.
Kutieshat, R. and Farmanesh, P. (2022) ‘The impact of new human resource management practices on innovation performance during the COVID 19 crisis: a new perception on enhancing the educational sector’, Sustainability, 14(5).
Leinwand, P., Mani, M. and Sheppard, B. (2022) ‘Reinventing your leadership team’, Harvard Business Review, 100(1), pp.61–69.
Liu, X. (2022) ‘Exploring the future value of Starbucks‘, Atlantis Press, pp. 793–800.
Liu, X., Li, J. and Lin, C.J. (2022) ‘A study on Starbucks’ promotion Strategies in the Chinese market from 1999 to 2009‘, pp. 1117–1120.
Livingston, R. (2020) ‘How to promote racial equity in the workplace’, Harvard Business Review, 98(5).
Muleya, D., Ngirande, H. and Terera, S.R. (2022) ‘The influence of training and career development opportunities on affective commitment: a South African higher education perspective’, SA Journal of Human Resource Management, 20.
Neeley, T. and Leonardi, P. (2022) ‘Developing a digital mindset: how to lead your organization into the age of data, algorithms, and AI’, Harvard Business Review, 100(5-6), pp.50–55.
Serafeim, G. (2020) ‘Social-Impact Efforts That Create Real Value Sustainability‘, Harvard Business Review, 98(5), pp. 38–48.
Shih, W. and Morlinghaus, C. (2020) ‘Summary operations global supply chains in a post-pandemic world’, Harvard Business Review, 98(5).
Sihombing, L.H. and Lestari, P. (2022) ‘Revealing the philosophy of Starbucks Logo: semiotic analysis’, ELTALL: English Language Teaching, Applied Linguistics and Literature, 3(2), pp. 24–35.
Starbucks (2022) Top 10 Things to Know about Starbucks 10 Years in India. Starbucks Stories Asia.
Tenbarge, K. (2023) ‘Social media fuels boycotts against McDonald’s and Starbucks over Israel-Hamas war‘, NBC News.
Yahui, L. et al. (2023) ‘How service quality influence customer satisfaction: a case study of Starbucks in Malaysia’, International Journal of Tourism and Hospitality in Asia Pacific (IJTHAP), 6(3), pp. 29–41.