Executive Summary
In the last decade, national setters of accounting standards have become aware of the emerging need for efficient standards that can be used to regulate financial institutions. Countries within the Middle East such as Bahrain, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Oman, Qatar, and the UAE have acknowledged the need to be proactively involved in financial opportunities and have been in the forefront in adopting the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). The primary aim of this research study is to highlight the accounting information value relevance in companies within Bahrain, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Oman, Qatar, and the UAE, which have embraced the IFRS in financial information reporting.
This could illustrate the outcome of integrating the IFRS on accounting information value relevance within the seven countries. Through portfolio and regression approaches, the results obtained indicated that there is value relevance in accounting information in the seven countries for companied that embraced the IFRS. A comparative analysis of the results obtained after and before adoption of the IFRS indicted an enhancement in value relevance of accounting information for these companies in all the seven countries. The results can be inferred to mean that adoption of the IFRS improved the accounting information value relevance in the companies that adopted the international standards in the seven countries.
Introduction
Research Background
Many countries in the Middle East have little or no reasonable accounting standards besides political and economic uncertainty. However, in the last two decades, economics reforms and different market liberalization policies have come into play within the Arab world markets. Specifically, accounting reforms within the Arab world, in terms of adaptation of the IFRS, have encouraged the maturity and development of the financial markets.
For instance, in Bahrain, Jordan, Oman, Qatar, and the UAE, the commercial companies law was passed in the year 2002 to requires firms to carrying out financial reporting, in terms of financial statements in line with the IFRS (Bade & Parkin 2013). In the year 2003, Kuwait and Lebanon followed the trend. By the year 2007, all companies listed in the respective securities markets had to follow the IFRS in publishing their financial statement (Deloitte 2007).
The quality and value of any accounting information is established by the level of satisfaction by the user of the information. Therefore, most of the accounting research is often carried out to establish the usefulness and relevance of the information highlighted through any accounting process. Basically, several factors affect the quality of accounting information such as regulatory devises in the form of accounting standards (Verriest 2007). This means that accounting standards that are of high quality might provide consistent, relevant, reliable, and comparable information on financial performance of an economy.
Despite inexistence of a standardised accounting quality definition, several quality dimensions have become accepted. The most common measure of accounting quality has been the value relevance approach, which can be used to assess the relevance of information on accounting for the consumption of the stakeholders. For instance, Beaver (2011) observed that “theoretical groundwork of value relevance studies is a combination of valuation theory plus contextual accounting and financial reporting arguments (accounting theory) that allows the researcher to predict how accounting variables” (Beaver 2011, p. 35).
Research Problem Statement
The purpose of this research project is to establish the underlying effects of adopting IFRS on the value relevance of accounting information for companies within the mentioned financial markets.
Hypothesis
Null Hypothesis (H0): Country specific factors do not have an effect on the value relevance of accounting information
Alternative hypotheis (H1) Hypothesis: Country specific factors have an effect on the value relevance of accounting information
Research Gap
Despite a series of researches in the western markets and efforts by respective governments to proactively develop their financial markets, there is no empirical study that has been carried out within the Arab world to establish the effect of IFSR on value relevance of accounting information. Therefore, this case study will aim at filling this research gap. The study will aim at investigating the value relevance of accounting information in the mentioned countries. Particularly, the study will establish whether quality and relevance of accounting information has improved within the seven countries or not, despite the efforts by these governments through accounting institutions to adopt the IFRS.
Research Contribution
The contribution of the proposed study is reviewing the value relevance in a context that has never been examined before within the Arab world. Another contribution is studying the impact of financial crisis on value-relevance in Arab countries. In addition, the proposed case study will review the impact of country-specific factors on value-relevance in Arab countries by using up to date institutional factors (Barzegari 2010). The findings of the research project will be beneficial to financial experts within the mentioned countries in making comprehensive and value relevant financial statements. Besides, the recommendations made may enable the companies within the mentioned markets to adopt the most sustainable financial reporting models within acceptable international and local accounting information standards.
Research Limitations and Delimitation
The findings of the proposed study might not be the only magic bullet in determining effectiveness of accounting information reporting within the mentioned markets and other economies in the Arab world. This means that the findings will only provide the trend in value relevance of accounting information within the Arab world following the adoption of the IFRS by companies operating in the mentioned countries. This means that the findings will be limited to the IFRS as the only determinant of value relevance of accounting information in the case study markets. In order to minimise this limitation, the research will be carried out to through regression and correlation to establish existing relations in each of the seven countries as independent cases.
Literature Review
Introduction
The literature review will be based on past case study researches, financial journals, academic books, and online finance websites such as yahoo.com, aastocks.com, reuters.com, google.com, and bloomberg.com. These sites are authentic since most of materials in them are from reputable firms. The academic journals to be used in this research paper will be selected from academic and authentic financial sites such as Pro Quest, Harvard Business Review, Emerald, ABI, google.com, and BNU e-database. The sources to be used in the paper will be forty, that is, twenty from academic journals and twenty from others sources such as books, pamphlets, past reports, and authentic websites.
Empirical Literature Review
Basically, a case study on value relevance of accounting information evaluates the existing relationship between market values and the actual accounting information. Several studies have been carried out in the past across the western markets to establish the link between equity values and accounting numbers. For instance, as early as the year 1966, there was a study carried out by Modigliani in 1966 on the value relevance of accounting information. This study employed data from the electricity industry to show that earnings on equity contribute the largest towards the marketplace value of a company or industry (Verriest 2007).
In another study carried out by Qystein and Frode (2007) to evaluate the value relevance of accounting information in Norway for a period of 40 years, the findings revealed that Norwegian GAAP value relevance did not decline for the entire period.
Several studies have been carried out on the performance of companies that follow the IFRS in terms of value relevance of accounting information. For instance, Barth (2008) established that “companies which follow IAS/IFRS voluntarily supply higher quality accounting information than companies that apply local accounting standards” (p. 34). Despite this revelation, the author was also categorical that economic and political factors might affect the financial reporting at local level even for companies that apply the IFRS standards. The institutional setting of a country might also influence the accuracy and relevance of accounting information as was established by a research by Ball and Brown (2006) within the European Union market.
A study by Dung (2010) testing the value-relevance of accounting information in terms of formation of financial statement within the Vietnamese stock market indicated that “the value relevance of accounting was statistically meaningful, though weaker than in other developed and emerging markets” (Dung 2010, p. 67). In another study by Filip (2010) to investigate the direct impact of adoption of the IFRS on the value relevance of accounting information within the Romania market, the results indicated that proactive and strategic IFRS implementation has the consequence of increasing the value relevance of the recorded earnings (Aljifri 2008).
Literature Discussion
The above literature indicate that adoption of the IFRS have positive effect on value relevance of accounting information for companies across the world. Specifically, companies that adopted international accounting standards such as the IFRS had better performance and value relevant accounting information. There are a number of qualities that enable the accounting information to satisfy the needs of various users. The first quality is that the accounting information is relevant. The information is presented in a way that it is able to influence the decision of a user (McLaney & Atrill 2008).
Besides, the information makes it possible for the users to be able to endorse past events and forecast future events easily. Further, the accounting information presented is often material. Thus, the information presented should not change materially in the event that errors or falsifications are established. This can be achieved through reinventing the conceptual framework of operations. The second quality is that accounting information gives a faithful representation of the financial position of the entity.
This implies that the accounting information is complete, neutral and free from error. Some of the other qualities are that accounting information is comparable, verifiable, timely, and understandable. Therefore, literature from the western market indicate that adoption of the IFRS have a positive effect on value relevance of accounting information in companies.
Impacts of Accounting Standards on Company Performance within the Arab World
Close to the countries under investigation, there are only three studies that were carried on the IASs for Bahrain and the UAE market environments. The first study was carried by Joshi and Basteki (1999) on the progress of the local accounting standards following the adoption of the IASs by the Bahrain accounting institutions (Ohlson 2009, Ho 2001).
The findings suggested that organizations operating within the Bahrain should be more proactive in adhering to the IASs standard and that its application should be regulated by the local accounting regulatory body (Thinggaarda & Damkierb 2008). The second study was carried out by Joshi and Ramadhan (2002) to examine different existing accounting practices and the level of adoption of the IASs by small and medium companies within the value market in Bahrain.
The findings revealed that 86% of the participating companies in the study were applying the IASs because they thought the standard was applicable in the preparation of accounting information. The last study was carried by Aljifri and Khasharmeh (2006) to investigate the IASs sustainability within the UAE market environment through nonparametric and parametric approaches. The findings revealed that majority of user groups of the IASs argued that it is sustainable and should be adopted by brokers, auditors, financial analysts, and financial managers in financial reporting within the UAE (Marat & Shoult 2005; Marquardt & Wiedman 2004). Besides, existing literature within the Arab market indicate that adoption of IASs have a positive impact on organization performance, in terms of financial reporting.
Summary of the Literature Review
As indicated in the findings of the empirical research on value relevance of accounting information, application of accounting standards have an impact of the quality of financial statement reporting. However, there is no empirical study on the effect of IFRS on value relevance of accounting information in mentioned countries. There is need to carry out research on the impact of IFRS on quality of accounting information within the above countries.
Methodology
Regression
Regression approach will be used to model the relationship between the dependent and the independent variables. This approach will be used to establish the ability of earnings to explain the annual market adjusted returns. In this case, the earnings return model will be suitable (Filip 2010; Hung 2001). The market return model that was developed by Easton and Harris (1991) has been commonly applied in research studies that investigate the value relevance (Easton & Harris 1991; Kothari 2004). This model makes use of the earning level and changes in the earnings as the independent variables while the dependent variable is the annual market return on stocks. Therefore, this model will be adapted to investigate the effect of country specific factors on the value of accounting information in the seven countries (Alijifri & Khasharmeh 2006; Hellstrom 2006). The earnings return model is specified below.
Rjt = β0 + β1EPSjt / Pjt-1 + β2(EPSjt – EPSjt-1) / Pjt-1 + ejt
Rjt represents the annual return of shares. It also includes the cash dividends paid
EPSjt represents the annual earnings per shares of the firms at time t
(EPSjt – EPSjt-1) represents the annual change in earnings per share between two consecutive periods
Pjt-1 represents the price of stock
ejt represents the error term
Correlation analysis
The analysis will show the nature of the relationship between the explanatory variables and the explained variables. Also, it will evaluate the explanatory power of the independent variables by evaluating the coefficient of determination (Baltagi 2011; Madura 2014). Therefore, the hypothesis will be tested using regression and correction analysis.
Data
The data collected comprises of the earnings per share and price of shares of 14 companies that are registered in the mentioned countries. The annual data of the variables are collected for the period between 2005 and 2014 (Creswell 2009; FrankfortNachmias & Nachmias 2008). Further, the data are collected from the Arab market database and the respective website of the stock exchange market for the mentioned countries (Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016). Data for the companies selected will be collected before the use of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) was adopted in these countries and after the adoption of the standard. A summary of data for the variables for the seven countries is presented below.
Kuwait
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
Lebanon
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
Bahrain
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
Qatar
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
UAE
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
Oman
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
Jordan
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
Results and Finding
Descriptive statistics
The table presented below will shows the descriptive statistics of all the variables that will be used in the earning models. The descriptive statistics will be classified into two groups, that is, before and after the adoption of IFRS (Bade and Parkin 2013; Verbeek 2008).
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
The column graph presented below shows a comparison of descriptive statistics for the seven countries.
Summary of descriptive statistics before and after the adoption of IFRS
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
Correlation analysis
The table presented below shows a summary of the correlation coefficient of the variables.
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
A positive correlation can be observed between the three countries in Kuwait, UAE, and Jordan. A negative association was observed in some variables in the other four countries (Berk 2004; Blank 2011; Vinod 2008).
Regression
The regression results for the seven countries are summarized in the tables below.
Kuwait
Lebanon
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
Bahrain
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
Qatar
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
UAE
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
Oman
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
Jordan
(Source: Zughaibi & Kabbani 2016).
Discussion
In the case of Kuwait, the explanatory power of the accounting information improved after the adoption of IFRS. This can be seen in the growth of the values of R-square from 15.009% before to 95.28% after the adoption of the set of standards (Field 2013). Also, there was an improvement in overall regression line and the explanatory power of the specific variables.
A similar trend was observed in Lebanon. The explanatory power improved from 16.74% before to 79.25% after the adoption of IFRS. The overall regression line also improved as indicated by the F-test (Filip & Raffournier 2010). The significance of the explanatory variables also improved after the adoption as indicated by the t-tests. In the case of Bahrain, the explanatory power of accounting information dropped after the adoption of IFRS.
The coefficient of determination dropped from 91.14% to 77.52%. However, the significance of the overall regression line improved. This shows that the adoption of the set of standards did not improve the explanatory power of the accounting information. In the case of Qatar, the coefficient of determination improved from 83.10% to 93.59%. The significance of the overall regression line also improved. A slight improvement of the explanatory power of accounting information was also observed in UAE.
The coefficient of determination grew from 97.24% before the adoption of IFRS to 99.17% after the adoption of the standard. In the case of Oman, the adoption of IFRS did not improve the explanatory power of accounting information. The value of R-square dropped from 96.82% to 71.66%. A similar trend was observed in the Jordan (Green & Salkind 2014; Greene 2011; Gujarati 2014; Verbeek 2008). The coefficient of determination grew from 99.96% before the adoption of IFRS to 81.86% after the adoption (Wang 2010; Zikmund et al. 2012).
The results show that the adoption of accounting IFRS (country specific factor) improved the relevance of accounting information in four out of the seven countries. Therefore, the null hypothesis will be rejected and this implies that country specific factors have an effect on the value relevance of accounting information.
Conclusion
There are a number of qualities that enable the accounting information to satisfy the needs of various users. Induction is the process of receiving accounts that are commencing their duties on accounting systems. Actually, an organization’s representative should introduce new employees both to the organization and other fellow employees, informing them the accounting traditions, events, and customs of the organization. The first quality is that the accounting information is relevant. The information is presented in a way that it is able to influence the decision of a user (McLaney & Atrill 2008).
Besides, the information makes it possible for the users to be able to endorse past events and forecast future events easily. Further, the accounting information presented is often material. Thus, the information presented should not change materially in the event that errors or falsifications are established. This can be achieved through reinventing the conceptual framework of operations. The second quality is that accounting information gives a faithful representation of the financial position of the entity (Green & Salkind 2014; Greene 2011; Gujarati 2014; Verbeek 2008). This implies that the accounting information is complete, neutral and free from error. Some of the other qualities are that accounting information is comparable, verifiable, timely, and understandable.
The findings indicate that accounting information value relevance in companies within Bahrain, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Oman, Qatar, and the UAE, has resulted in improved financial performance of these companies. Through regression approach, the results obtained indicated that there is value relevance in accounting information in the seven countries for companied that embraced the IFRS.
A comparative analysis of the results obtained after and before adoption of the IFRS indicted an enhancement in value relevance of accounting information for these companies in all the seven countries. The results can be inferred to mean that adoption of the IFRS improved the accounting information value relevancy in the companies that adopted the international standards in the seven countries.
Reference List
Alijifri, K & Khasharmeh, H. 2006. “An investigation into the suitability of the international accounting standards to the United Arab Emirates environment,” International Business Review, vol. 15, no. 3, pp. 505-526.
Aljifri, K. 2008. “Annual report disclosure in a developing country: the case of the UAE,” Advances in International Accounting, vol. 7, no. 6, pp. 45-65.
Bade, R., & Parkin M. 2012. Essential foundations of economics, Pearson Education, New York.
Ball, R & Brown, P. 2006. “An empirical evaluation of accounting income numbers,” Journal of Accounting Research, vol. 6, no. 3, pp. 159-178.
Baltagi, B. 2011. Econometrics, Springer Publishers, New York.
Barth, M. 2008. “Fair value accounting: Evidence from investment securities and the market valuation of banks,” Accounting Review, vol. 69, no. 5, pp. 1–25.
Barzegari, K. 2010. Value relevance of accounting information in selected middle east countries, University Putra Malaysia, Selangor, Malaysia.
Beaver L. 2011. “Perspectives on recent capital market research,” Accounting Review, vol. 77, no. 5, pp. 453-474.
Berk, R. 2004. Regression analysis: A constructive critique, SAGE Publishers, New York.
Blank, K. 2011. Business statistics: For contemporary decision making, John Wiley & Sons, New Jersey.
Creswell, J. W. 2009. Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA.
Deloitte. 2007. IAS Plus 2007. Web.
Dung, N. 2010. Value-relevance of financial statement information: A flexible Application of modern theories to the Vietnamese stock market, Saisko Publishers, Vietnam.
Easton, P & Harris, T. 1991. “Earnings as an explanatory variable for returns,” Journal of Accounting Research, vol. 29, no. 1, pp. 45-78.
Field, A. 2013. Discovering statistics using IBM SPSS statistics, SAGE Publication, London.
Filip, A & Raffournier, B. 2010. “The value relevance of earnings in a transition economy: The case of Romania,” The International Journal of Accounting vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 77-103.
Filip, A. 2010. “IFRS and the value relevance of earnings: evidence from the emerging market of Romania,” International Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Performance Evaluation, vol. 6, no. 6, pp. 191-223.
FrankfortNachmias, C & Nachmias, D. 2008. Research methods in the social sciences, Worth, New York.
Green, S & Salkind 2014. Using SPSS for Windows and Macintosh: Analyzing and understanding data, Pearson, Upper Saddle River.
Greene, W. 2011. Econometric analysis, Pearson Education, New York.
Gujarati, D. 2014. Econometrics by Example, Palgrave Macmillan, New York.
Haber, J. 2004. Accounting dimistified, American Management Association, New York.
Hellstrom, K. 2006. “The value relevance of financial accounting information in a transitional economy: The case of the Czech Republic,” European Accounting review, vol. 15, no. 3, pp. 325-349.
Ho, P. 2001. The value relevance of accounting information around the 1997 Asian financial crisis – The case of South Korea, University of Texas at Arlington, New York.
Hung, M 2001, “Accounting Standards and value relevance of financial statements: An international analysis,” Journal of Accounting and Economics, vol. 30, no. 3, pp. 401-420.
Joshi, K & Al-Basteki, H. 1999. “Development of Accounting Standards and Adoption of IASs: Perceptions of accountants from a developing country,” Asian Review of Accounting, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 23-45.
Joshi, P & Ramadhan, S. 2002. “The adoption of international accounting standards by small and closely held companies: evidence from Bahrain,” The International Journal of Accounting, vol. 37, no. 3, pp. 429–440.
Kothari, J. 2004. Research methodology: Methods and techniques, New Age International (P) Limited Publishers, New Delhi.
Madura, J. 2014. International financial management, Cengage Learning, New York.
Marat, T & Shoult, A. 2005. Doing business with Bahrain: A guide to investment accounting standards to the United Arab Emirates environment,” International Business, vol. 37, no. 3, pp. 429–440.
Marquardt, K & Wiedman, M. 2004. “The effect of earnings management on the value relevance of accounting information,” Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, vol. 31, no. 5, pp. 297–332.
Ohlson, J. 2009. “Earnings, book values, and dividends in equity valuation,” Contemporary Accounting Research, vol. 11, no. 2, pp. 661-669.
Qystein, K & Frode S. 2007. The value-relevance of financial reporting in Review, vol. 15, no. 7, pp. 505–526.
Thinggaarda, F & Damkierb, J. 2008. “Has financial statement information become less relevant? Longitudinal evidence from Denmark,” Scandinavian Journal of Management, vol. 3, no. 6, pp. 59-78.
Verbeek, M. 2008. A guide to modern econometrics, John Wiley & Sons, New York.
Verriest, A. 2007. “The evolution of accounting quality: An international comparison,” The International Journal of Accounting, vol. 37, no. 3, pp. 429–440.
Vinod, H. 2008. Hands on intermediate econometrics using R: Templates for extending dozens of practical examples, World Scientific Publishers, New Jersey.
Wang, J. 2010. Business intelligence in economic forecasting: Technologies and techniques, IGI Global, London.
Zikmund, W, Babin, B, Carr, J & Griffin, M. 2012. Business research methods, Cengage Learning, Alabama.
Zughaibi, K, & Kabbani, B. 2016. GCC stock market indices, Web.